Ideal Leaders In Lord Of The Flies Essay

Ralph, Jack and swinish all allow singular qualities. Are any of them ideal attractors? What important qualities do individually of them possess (and lack) as regards leaders?Who is the natural leader in superior of the Flies? This is the question that Golding is making us consider. in that respect is no obligation or wrong answer, as all of the boys possess unique lead qualities. This essay will explore what qualities of leadership Ralph, loutish and Jack possess (and lack), and til nowtually come to a conclusion (if one can be found) as to which boy is the natural leader of the band of boys on the island.A leader is somebody who guides a group in whatever they do. They convey policies, rules and, if necessary, decisions for the group that they lead, which the group should then follow.Ralph has a number of ideal leadership qualities. He is fair, maybe sometimes too fair, and believes in the idea of everyone having a chance to oblige their say (Ill give the conch to the next psyche to speak. He can hold it when hes speakingAnd he wont be interrupted. Except by me. 31) However, the rule of independence of speech is overturned by Jack (Jack was the first to convey himself heard. He had non got the conch and thus spoke against the rules, simply nobody minded. 94) and Ralph does not do anything ab divulge it.This is one of the qualities that Ralph lacks. He discovers rules, but is not spontaneous to enforce them because he fears that they may be ignored (You got to be overweight-bitten now, make em do what you want. If I blow the conch and they dont come back, then weve had it 99) unless something happens to spur him to action, such as when Jack let the fire aside (So Ralph asserted his chieftainship and could not have chosen a better way if he had thought for days. Against this weapon, so indefinable and so effective, Jack was powerless and raged without sack outing why 77)Ralph believes in everyone having responsibility and everyone worki ng together and helping each other to advance a successful community. He offers the groups long term solutions such as shelters and a signal fire so that they would be rescued, however, he does not do enough to make these ideas attractive, and as a result he ends up doing most of the work while the hunters and littluns disappear to have period of play (And they keep running off. You remember the meeting?How everyone was going to work hard until the shelters were finished?, When the meeting was over theyd work for five proceeding then wander off or go hunting. 51) This lack of word sense of responsibility annoys him and makes him hostile (As they danced, they sang. Kill the pig. Cut her throat. Bash her in. Ralph watched them, wishful and resentful. 79) towards Jack and the hunters. As a result, he is not as handsome of them as he should have been and eventually insults that part of the group (What to a higher place my hunters? Boys armed with sticks. 137) This makes Jack angry enough to attempt to rebel against Ralphs leadership, and straight after he leaves to start a tribe of his own.He is very right-hand(a) at communication. He says what he thinks rather than essay to hide his own opinions and feelings (Better Piggy than superfatted, Ralph said with the directness of legitimate leadership., I was chief, and you were going to do what I said. You talk. But you cant even build huts-then you go off hunting and let out the fire- 21/22) This is essential, because if you do not let others know your feelings, then they will not understand why you are acting the way you are, or your reasons for making decisions, and might think you are being unreasonable.He can make his speeches simple for the littluns to understand, yet powerful by using repetition and account (He had learnt as a practical business that fundamental statements likes this had to be said at least twice, before everyone understood themHis mind was prying for simple words so that even the l ittluns would understand what the assembly was about. 84) However, as events spiral out of his control, his speeches become less and less inspiring as he loses confidence in himself and his abilities, and eventually his followers desert him and he is left on his own, running for his life.Though Ralph is a natural leader (There was a stillness about Ralph as he sit smooth that marked him outand most obscurely, yet most powerfully, there was the conch. The being that had blown thatwas set apart 19), able to reassure and offer sympathizer (The assembly was lifted towards safety by his words. They liked and now value him. 36), the values and goals that he presents as part of his leadership do not offer the security that the group needs when their morale is low as a result of fear of the beast.As a result, he is more(prenominal)over able to lead when times are good. He clings to the same ideals that he had when he first came to the island the idea of rescue, keeping civilisation in tact and having rules, and is uneffective to adapt to the changing feelings on the island about those ideals when they are overtaken by more immediate and attractive offers (Because the rules are the barely thing weve got Bollocks to the rules Were strong we hunt If theres a beast, well hunt it down Well close in and beat and beat and beat- 99)Piggy supports Ralph in his leadership, but does not have the popularity to be a leader himself. He possesses a number of leadership qualities, but because of his unpopularity, he is often ignored (There had grown up tacitly among the biguns the opinion that Piggy was an outsider, not only by accent, which did not matter, but by fat, and ass-mar, and specs, and a certain reluctance for manual labour. 68)Because of this, when important matters needing his input occur, his valuable ideas are often cut (We ought to be more careful. Im scared- Youre eternally scared. Yah Fatty 45) He is intelligent, and most of the sensible, good ideas come from him (what intelligence had been shown was traceable to Piggy 18/19 Ralph We can use this the conch to call the others. Have a meeting. 12 Piggy move among the crowd, asking names and frowning to remember them. 14 We havent make a fire whats any use. We couldnt keep a fire like that going if we tried. 41 The first thing we ought to have make was shelters down on the beach. 45)He is also a very good judge of character, though he seems blind when it comes to seeing that the others, Ralph included, do not like him (He hates me Jack. I dunno why. If he could do what he treasured youre all right, he respects youI tell you what. He hates you too, RalphHe cant hurt you, but if you stand out of the way hed hurt the next thing. And thats me. 100/101) However, his pessimism (Theyre all dead an this is an island. Nobody dont know were here. Your dad dont know, nobody dont know We may stay here till we die. 9), his complaining and his dislike of manual labour leads to the other boys re garding him as being no use to the group, so they shout him down whenever he tries to speak (His voice lifted into the blub of virtuous recrimination.The others stirred and began to shout him down. 43) If Piggy and Ralph had worked together right at the beginning, with Ralph listening to Piggys ideas instead of regarding him as an irritation (Piggy was a bore his fat, his ass-mar and his matter-of-fact ideas were dull but there was always a little pleasure to be got out of pulling his leg, even if one did it by accident. 68), then Piggys intelligence and Ralphs popularity and dedication to work would have combined to make an excellent correlative leadership which most of the group would have accepted.